Thomas Selmont, Connecticut firearms appraiser and expert witness

Partner, CT Firearms Auction  ·  Founder, CT Gun Broker

Thomas Selmont

Firearms Appraiser  ·  Auctioneer  ·  Expert Witness

Thomas A. Selmont is a Connecticut firearms appraiser, auctioneer and expert witness with more than 20 years of leadership experience in regulated and collectible assets, insurance and litigation support. Attorneys, fiduciaries, insurers and collectors rely on him for objective valuations, compliant disposition and clear guidance through federal and Connecticut firearms law. Around Connecticut, he’s known simply as “The Professional Gun Guy.”

20+ Years

Of leadership in regulated assets, insurance and litigation support

3,000–5,000

Firearms appraised, cataloged and sold each year at CT Firearms Auction

500+ Guns

The size of the largest estate collections he has appraised

Every firearm has a story and a fair value. My job is to find both, document them honestly, and make sure the gun changes hands the right way.

Thomas Selmont

About Tom

Tom Selmont is a lifelong Connecticut native, entrepreneur and public servant who has built his career where firearms, valuation, insurance and the law meet. He founded CT Gun Broker, a licensed firearms dealer, in 2015, and in 2017 co-founded Connecticut Firearms Auction in Plantsville with auctioneer Ryan Brechlin. As Partner, Firearms Expert and Auctioneer there, he oversees the appraisal, cataloging, compliance, marketing and sale of roughly 3,000 to 5,000 firearms every year, from flintlocks and early American arms to modern transferable machine guns.

His appraisal work supports probate, bankruptcy, divorce, litigation, insurance, fiduciary and private-collection matters, with assignments ranging from a single heirloom to estates of more than 500 firearms. He is retained as an independent valuation expert and has testified in Connecticut Probate Courts, Connecticut Superior Court and New York estate proceedings.

Tom’s background makes him unusually well rounded for this work. He has held a Connecticut all-lines insurance license since 2007 and has run his own independent insurance agency, TSEL Group, since 2010, so he understands claims and coverage from the inside. Before that he managed a $1.2 million department and presented to a board of directors, and he worked in estate and retirement planning alongside tax attorneys and CPAs. He is also a Partner and Auctioneer with Good Bottle Auctions, which specializes in rare whiskey, wine and collectible spirits.

Credentials & Licenses

Federal Firearms LicenseeType 01 Dealer, CT Gun Broker, LLC (November 2015 to present)
Insurance LicenseState of Connecticut, all lines (August 2007 to present)
AuctioneerPartner and Auctioneer, Connecticut Firearms Auction (2017 to present) and Good Bottle Auctions (2023 to present)
Expert WitnessTestimony and expert support in Connecticut Probate Courts, Connecticut Superior Court and New York estate proceedings
PresenterConnecticut Bar Association, “Firearms and Their Appearance in Probate Proceedings” (2024)
U.S. PatentCo-inventor, U.S. Patent No. 8,545,904 B1 (2013)
Elected OfficePlanning and Zoning Commissioner, Town of Cheshire
MilitaryStaff Sergeant, Second Company Governor’s Foot Guard
Emergency ServicesFirefighter II (State of Connecticut, 2010) and EMT-Basic (State of Connecticut, 2006)
EducationYale University open course study (2011 to 2013)

Expert Witness & Litigation Support

Tom is retained as an independent firearms valuation expert and consultant in probate, estate administration, insurance, bankruptcy, divorce and civil litigation. He prepares objective appraisal reports and valuation opinions on individual firearms, regulated firearms, historic arms and major estate collections, and he advises attorneys, executors, administrators, trustees and insurers on valuation, market context, compliance and the practical handling of firearms within legal proceedings.

Selected Case Appearances

  • Estate of John J. Schmalbach, Case No. 24-00044, Housatonic Probate Court: expert testimony
  • Winakor, Administrator of the Estate of David Peikes v. Sementilli, Docket No. KNL-CV21-605636-S, New London Superior Court: expert witness
  • Numerous appearances and testimony in Probate Courts across Connecticut and New York involving valuation, market analysis, compliance and disposition of firearms collections

Representative Engagements

  • Insurance claim review: Reviewed a 161-firearm fire-loss claim for an independent claims adjuster, delivering a line-by-line review schedule that flagged significant overvaluations on Colt percussion revolvers and high-grade shotguns, as well as an undervalued line
  • Large estates: Appraised probate collections from single firearms to estates of more than 500 guns
  • Regulated firearms: Valuation and transfer guidance for National Firearms Act items, including transferable machine guns
  • Cross-border paperwork: Connecticut transfer documentation and Receipts of Acquisition for New York permit holders

Speaking & Education

On February 20, 2024, Tom presented to the Connecticut Bar Association with the Hon. Matthew Jalowiec on “Firearms and Their Appearance in Probate Proceedings.” The program covered federal and Connecticut law governing firearms transactions and the practical, legal, valuation and administrative issues that come up when firearms appear in a probate estate.

Tom is available to speak to bar associations, probate and elder law groups, estate planners, insurance professionals and collector organizations.

Areas of Expertise

Valuation & Appraisal

Fair market value appraisals for single firearms and full collections: pre-auction estimates, probate and estate appraisals, insurance appraisals, and valuations for bankruptcy and divorce. Every number is backed by documented sales data and recognized condition standards.

Expert Witness Work

Objective, defensible valuation opinions and testimony for probate and civil litigation, with experience in Connecticut Probate Courts, Connecticut Superior Court and New York estate proceedings.

Insurance & Loss Claims

More than 15 years as a licensed insurance professional. Independent review of firearms claims, including fire losses, checking each line for identification, condition and value and documenting findings in a clear, auditable report.

Estates & Probate

Guidance for executors, administrators, trustees and estate attorneys: inventory, appraisal, secure removal, legal transfer and sale of firearms from an estate, often without the family ever handling a gun.

Federal & Connecticut Compliance

Executive oversight of ATF requirements, Connecticut State Police matters, municipal compliance and National Firearms Act transfers, plus Connecticut DPS-3-C transfer documentation and New York permit paperwork.

Historic & Antique Arms

Historical research, authentication and cataloging of firearms from flintlocks and early American arms through Civil War carbines and 20th-century collectibles, with attention to originality, finish and provenance.

Auction Strategy

Advice on when a firearm will bring more at auction than in an outright sale, how to present a collection, and what to expect from cataloging through settlement.

Collection Acquisition

Outright purchase of single firearms, collections and entire estates through CT Gun Broker, with offers based on current market value.

Rare Whiskey & Wine

Through Good Bottle Auctions, valuation and auction of rare whiskey, wine and collectible spirits, a natural companion when estates hold both firearms and fine bottles.

What Clients Say

From Tom’s 4.9-star Google reviews.

Outstanding experience while selling inventory from my Dad’s estate. Tom was friendly, polite and knowledgeable… I would recommend Tom to anyone who is dealing with firearms from an estate.

Jim D., Google review

I had to ship guns in an Estate to Maryland – Tom processed all the required paperwork and shipped the guns, which have safely arrived. He is easy to talk to and knows everything gun and gun law related!!

Linda B., Google review

Tom is a highly professional, prudent and ethical business owner… Tom is especially committed to “due diligence and adherence to regulatory process.”

Richard C., Google review

Went in today to sell some antique Revolvers. I had the pleasure of speaking with Tom about the history behind my collection and the worth of them. He was very helpful and the process was simple and easy as well as fair with the price of my collection.

Hector R., Google review

Who Tom Works With

  • Probate, estate and elder law attorneys settling estates that include firearms
  • Bankruptcy, divorce and litigation attorneys who need a defensible valuation
  • Executors, administrators, trustees and families who need firearms appraised, removed and sold legally
  • Insurance adjusters and carriers evaluating theft, fire and other loss claims
  • Collectors buying, selling, insuring or documenting a collection
Thomas Selmont at the CT Firearms Auction booth, New York Sportsman’s Expo in Syracuse

Career Timeline

Age 17Opened his first business, T&T Pools
2002–2007NAMCO, LLC: rose from retail sales to Director of Services, managing a 7 to 12 person department and a $1.2 million budget presented to the Board of Directors
2007–2010Seneco & Associates: estate and retirement planning with life insurance and advanced financial products, working alongside tax attorneys and CPAs
2007Licensed by the State of Connecticut as an all-lines insurance producer
2010Founded TSEL Group, LLC, an independent multi-line insurance agency in Wallingford
2013Issued U.S. Patent No. 8,545,904 B1 as co-inventor
2015Founded CT Gun Broker, LLC, a Type 01 Federal Firearms Licensee in Wallingford
2016Met auctioneer Ryan Brechlin while working on an estate with a large firearms collection
2017Co-founded Connecticut Firearms Auction in Plantsville as Partner, Firearms Expert and Auctioneer
2023Became Partner and Auctioneer of Good Bottle Auctions, specializing in rare whiskey, wine and spirits
2024Presented to the Connecticut Bar Association on firearms in probate proceedings

Public Service & Leadership

  • Planning and Zoning Commissioner, Town of Cheshire (elected)
  • Board Member, The Geronimo Foundation, Wallingford, a nonprofit devoted to veteran recognition, living history, education and historical preservation
  • Staff Sergeant, Second Company Governor’s Foot Guard, taking part in official state ceremonies, military honors and historic commemorations
  • Firefighter II with the West Ridge Fire Association in North Haven for about a decade
  • EMT-Basic with Nelson Ambulance

Research & Innovation

Tom’s research interests include American Civil War-era firearms technology, especially carbines and the development of metallic cartridges; firearms design, manufacturing and distribution from the Industrial Revolution through the 1980s; firearms law and regulation past, present and future; and the preservation and responsible disposition of historic and regulated collectibles.

An entrepreneur since he opened his first business at 17, Tom is also a named co-inventor of U.S. Patent No. 8,545,904 B1, a topical skin-care formulation made with andiroba oil. He continued his education through Yale University’s open course program.

Wood-stocked hunting rifle in a pine forest

Outside the Office

Tom is an avid hunter who spends as much time as he can in the New England outdoors, including trips deep into the Maine wilderness. He loves a good treasure hunt and the thrill of finding real value where others might overlook it, which is a big part of why he enjoys estate work.

He lives in Cheshire with his wife, Sandy, and their three children.

Work With Tom

Need an appraisal, an expert opinion, a second look at a claim, or help with firearms in an estate? Tom offers consultations by appointment.